- All Day Menu
- HAPPY HOUR
- MONDAYS
- TUESDAYS
- THURSDAYS
- FRIDAYS
- SATURDAYS
- Sunday Brunch
- Cocktails, Beer, Wine & Spirits
- Dessert
- Kids Menu
- Group Price Fixe Menu
A menu for everyone; comfort food, fresh salads, sandwiches, and daily specials highlighting our surrounding area & seasons
Start with soup and go from there...
-
South Street Chowder
our classic chowder; new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, fresh herbs
Pint $13.50
gluten free
-
Roasted Beet Salad
whipped goat cheese, toasted pistachio, balsamic glaze, pickled red onions, arugula & fennel
$18
gluten free
Roast chicken $9.27
Sautéed shrimp $11.33
-
Kale Caesar Salad
baby kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, apples, roasted garlic croutons (gf available)
$16.50
-
First Street Wedge
Point Reyes blue cheese crumble & dressing, baby iceberg, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote, chives
$21
gluten free
-
Salad Additions
roast chicken $12
sautéed shrimp $12
fried tofu $6
seared salmon $14
seared steak $16
-
Bread Service
baguette with house herb butter
$5
-
First Fries
hand cut, blanched idaho potatoes
$10.25
dairy free, gluten free, vegetarian
-
Cheese Fries
house-made fries, all the cheese
$15.25
gluten free
-
Disco Fries
gravy, queso, fresh herbs
$18.25
-
Our House Made Sauces
$2.25
chipotle aioli
Point Reyes blue cheese
goat cheese ranch
lemon garlic aioli
black garlic aioli
whole grain honey mustard
scallion remoulade
wasabi aioli
truffle aioli
malt vinegar aioli
cajun buffalo sauce
-
Mac & Cheese
4 cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumbs (can be served gf)
For One $19
add cremini mushroom & truffle oil $7.25
add roast chicken $12
add sautéed garlic spinach $4.15
gluten free pasta $4.12
add applewood smoked bacon lardons $6.15
-
Oysters Rockefeller
broiled local oysters, pernod garlic cream, spinach, parmesan, goat cheese
3 for $19
6 for $31
gluten free
-
Burrata
confit cherry tomatoes, garlic & shallots, basil pesto, radish sprouts, warm baguette
$17
-
Maple Carrots
savory hummus, arugula, toasted pine nuts, water vinaigrette, black sea salt
$18
gluten free
-
Saffron Mussels
lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette
$22
-
Buffalo Wings
traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, celery, carrots
$19
gluten free
-
Buttermilk Ranch Wings
dry rub ranch spices & buttermilk powder, goat cheese ranch dressing, celery, carrots
$19
gluten free
-
A Really Good Burger
seasoned 8oz patty, first fries, lettuce, tomato, pickle
$17.50
dairy free
-
Add to Your Burger
cheddar / gruyere / caramelized onions $2.50
steakhouse bacon $4.25
gluten free bun $4.25
-
Fried Chicken Sandwich
shredded cabbage, carrot & pickle slaw, russian dressing, sliced tomato, seasonal green salad (gf available)
$24
-
Black Bean Burger
queso fresco, caramelized onion, guacamole, chipotle aioli, seasonal green salad (gf available)
$22
dairy free, vegetarian
-
Tuna Burger
grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onions, seasonal green salad (gf available)
$27
dairy free
-
Lemon Pepper Shrimp
white wine garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, fusilli pasta, baguette (gf available)
$28
-
Angel Hair Pomodoro
blistered baby heirloom tomatoes, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nuts (gf available)
$24.75
butter & herb shrimp $11.33
roast chicken $9.27
-
Steak Frites
plancha grilled hangar steak, green salad, first fries, black garlic-merlot demi
$42.25
gluten free
-
Roast Chicken
wild mushroom bread pudding, wilted spinach, charred onion, almonds, marsala-caper sauce
$29
-
Honey & Tangerine Salmon
sautéed rainbow chard, shiitake, mushroom, lemon butter, garlic, shallots, scallions, jasmine rice
$34
3-5pm Weekdays Only
Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday !!!
HAPPY HOUR
Weekdays 3-5pm food & drink specials-
Draft Crafts
rotating selection of micro breweries & Guinness on tap
$6.50
-
Wines
rosé, prosecco, muscadet, pinot grigio, montepulciano & pinot noir
$8.50
-
"Call" Drinks
two part mixers
$8.50
-
Signature Drinks
44N Huckleberry, Mules, Aperol Spritz, Dark & Stormy
$10.50
-
HH Oysters
6 for $14
12 for $26
-
First Fries
triple blanched, made with love
$6.50
-
HH Mac & Cheese
four cheese mornay, garlic herb breadcrumbs
$10.50
-
Buffalo Wings
cajun sauce, blue cheese, celery
$12
gluten free
To Go Specialty Items & Gear
A selection of our handmade products to share at home...as well as our tee shirts, long sleeves & sweatshirts.-
Homemade Irish Cream
$24.72
-
Bloody Mary Guts
$15.45
-
First & South Coffee Mug
$17.30
-
Holiday Ornament
Artist Kelly Franké's line drawing of the corner of First and South on porcelain circle with gold ribbon
$15.45
-
First & South Greenport Wear
Black Short Sleeve $22.66
Green Long Sleeve $25.75
Crop Top $22.66
Red Kids Sweatshirt $39.14
Black Pullover Hoodie $46.35
Blue Zip-Up Hoodie $59.14
Mondays, year-round offer mussels & first fries all day $19
Happy Hour 3-5pm!
Stay tuned for dinner specials.
Lunch 12-5pm
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Monday Mussels
andouille sausage, tomato, garlic, shallots, fresh herbs, beer butter broth, First Fries
gluten free
-
Avocado Egg Salad Sandwich
dill, parsley, cornichon, avocado, citrus, black sea salt, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad
-
Blue Crab Salad
papaya, daikon radish cress, cherry tomato, soybean sprout, red bell pepper, mint, cilantro, garlic & ginger coconut-lime dressing
-
Fish & Chips
crispy cod, asian slaw, wasabi aioli & eel sauce, First Fries
gluten free
-
Steak Sandwich
peppercorn crusted flat iron steak, pepper jack cheese, roasted red peppers, arugula, chipotle aioli, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad
Dinner 5-9pm
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Roasted Oysters
basil pesto, parmesan, panko, chives
gluten free
-
Monday Mussels
andouille sausage, tomato, garlic, shallots, fresh herbs, beer butter broth, First Fries
gluten free
-
Peppercorn Crusted Steak
10oz prime flat iron, butter roasted broccoli & leeks, crispy potatoes, roasted garlic compound butter
dairy free, shellfish free, gluten free
-
Blackened Fluke
lemon-caper beurre blanc, asparagus, mashed potatoes, fine herbs
dairy free, gluten free
Tuesdays feature handmade pupusas & tacos all day & happy hour 3-5pm, LIVE MUSIC 6-9PM.
Lunch 12-5pm
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
House Made Guacamole & Chips
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Blue Crab Salad
papaya, daikon radish cress, cherry tomato, soybean sprout, red bell pepper, mint, cilantro, garlic & ginger coconut-lime dressing
-
Handmade Pupusas
mozzarella cheese, curtido slaw, pickled vegetable escabeche, tomato salsa, guacamole
gluten free
-
Handmade Tacos
two hand pressed corn tortillas, shredded cabbage, pineapple pico, salsas roja & verde, seasoned yucca fries
Dinner 5-9pm
Live Music; outside on our patio 6-9pm-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Handmade Pupusas
mozzarella cheese, curtido slaw, pickled vegetable escabeche, tomato salsa, guacamole
gluten free
-
Handmade Tacos
two hand pressed corn tortillas, shredded cabbage, pineapple pico, salsas roja & verde, seasoned yucca fries
LIVE MUSIC SCHEDULE
Every Tuesday 6-9pm YEAR ROUND and the First Friday of every month-
4/30 Julia King
6-9pm
-
5/7 Jeff LeBlanc
6-9pm
THURSDAYS 12-9pm
Happy Hour 3-5pm (weekdays only)
Lunch
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Sticky Wings
smoky BBQ, tamari, honey, garlic, toasted sesame, asian slaw, scallion
dairy free, sesame
-
Fish & Chips
crispy cod, asian slaw, wasabi aioli & eel sauce, First Fries
gluten free
HAPPY HOUR
Weekdays 3-5pm food & drink specials-
Happy Hour 3-5pm Monday - Friday
Tap craft beers, old world tap wines & ‘call’ mixed drinks all on special from 3-5pm
Dinner
served after 5pm-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Sticky Wings
smoky BBQ, tamari, honey, garlic, toasted sesame, asian slaw, scallion
dairy free, sesame
-
Blue Crab Salad
papaya, daikon radish cress, cherry tomato, soybean sprout, red bell pepper, mint, cilantro, garlic & ginger coconut-lime dressing
-
Pad Thai (after 5pm)
rice noodles, crispy tofu, cilantro, basil, toasted peanuts, crispy garlic, tamarind, sriracha
-
FRESH CATCH
coconut milk poached fluke, asparagus, pearl onion, mushroom, lemon, ginger, dill, jasmine rice
gluten free
OYSTER NIGHT
Happy Hour 3-5pm (weekdays)
Lunch & Dinner 12-9pm
Lunch Specials
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Roasted Oysters
basil pesto, parmesan, panko, chives
gluten free
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Greek Salad
mesclun greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
-
Oyster Basket
crispy local oysters, chipotle slaw, scallion remoulade, First Fries
gluten free
Dinner Specials
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Roasted Oysters
basil pesto, parmesan, panko, chives
gluten free
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Lump Crab Salad
asparagus, avocado, shallot, bean sprout, arugula, djion vinaigrette, parmesan basket
-
Greek Salad
mesclun greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
-
Coconut & Ginger Fluke
pan roasted local fluke, mushrooms, asparagus, pearl onions, dill, coconut milk, lemon, jasmine rice
BUTCHER BLOCK SPECIALS (Dinner only)
Lunch & Dinner 12-9pm
Lunch Specials
-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Greek Salad
mesclun greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
-
Blue Claw Crab Cake Sandwich
hearts of palm/papaya/mung bean/scallion slaw, garlic, ginger & sesame dressing, arugula, seasonal green salad
-
Oyster Basket
crispy local oysters, chipotle slaw, scallion remoulade, First Fries
gluten free
Dinner Specials
Beginning at 5pm-
Oysters on the Half Shell
EEL TOWN, SHELTER ISLAND - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
-
Roasted Oysters
basil pesto, parmesan, panko, chives
gluten free
-
Chicken Tortilla Soup
housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, black beans, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish
gluten free
-
Greek Salad
mesclun greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
-
Butcher Block | Dry Aged Pork Chop
asparagus, sweet potato puree, pineapple glaze
-
FRESH CATCH
coconut milk poached fluke, asparagus, pearl onion, mushroom, lemon, ginger, dill, jasmine rice
gluten free
Served 10:00 am to 3:00 pm
Last Call at the bar 4:30pm
Many of our lunch sandwiches & snacks are also available
Brunch Favorites
-
South Street Chowder
new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, cream, fresh herbs
gluten free
-
Oyster Rockefeller
broiled local oysters, pernod garlic cream, parmesan, goat cheese, spinach
gluten free
-
Roasted Beet Salad
whipped goat cheese, toasted pistachio, balsamic glaze, pickled red onions, arugula & fennel
gluten free
-
The Wedge
Point Reyes blue cheese crumbles & dressing, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote, chives
-
Caesar
baby kale, shaved parmesan, toasted walnuts, sliced apples, garlic croutons
-
Add To Any Salad
-
Burrata
confit cherry tomatoes, garlic & shallots, basil pesto, radish sprouts, warm baguette
-
Maple Carrots
savory hummus, arugula, toasted pine nuts, water vinaigrette, black sea salt
gluten free
-
Buffalo Wings
traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, celery, carrots
gluten free
-
First Fries for Two
hand cut, blanched with LOVE
-
French Toast
seasonal fruit, pure maple syrup, fresh whipped cream
-
Farm Frittata
seasonal ingredients, green salad
-
Fried Chicken & Buttermilk Biscuit
country gravy, breakfast potatoes
-
Eggs Benedict
english muffins, wilted spinach, poached eggs, old bay dusted hollandaise, breakfast potatoes with a choice...
-
Tuna Burger
grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onion, seasonal green salad
-
Black Bean Burger
queso fresco, caramelized onion, guacamole, chipotle aioli, seasonal green salad (gf available)
dairy free
-
Brunch Burger
pepper-jack cheese, sautéed mushrooms & onions, fried egg, pickle, First Fries
-
Fried Chicken Sandwich
shredded cabbage, carrot & pickle slaw, russian dressing, sliced tomato, seasonal green salad (gf available)
-
Avocado Egg Salad Sandwich
dill, parsley, cornichon, avocado, citrus, black sea salt, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad
-
Green Goddess Chicken Salad
Roasted & shredded chicken, tarragon, dill, parsley, greek yogurt, mayo, citrus, lettuce, tomato, toasted sourdough, first fries
-
Fish & Chips
crispy cod, asian slaw, wasabi aioli & eel sauce, First Fries
gluten free
-
Oyster Basket
two breaded, crispy local oysters, coleslaw, scallion remoulade
gluten free
To Share
-
Fresh Fruit
seasonal selection
-
Pop Tart
handmade with LOVE, seasonal fruit filling
-
Breakfast Potato
paprika, garlic & onion glazed
-
Warm Biscuits
seasonal marmalade
-
Steakhouse Bacon
Cocktails
-
Boris & Natasha
rosé, Figenza vodka, St. Germain, fresh lemon, club soda
-
Yuzu Zuzu
grey whale gin, yuzu, green tea, grapefruit
-
Chai Old Fashioned
chai infused redemption rye whiskey, simple syrup, angostura bitters
-
Olvera Heist
spicy silver tequila, pamplemousse, lime
-
Huckleberry Lemonade
44 North Huckleberry vodka, mint, house lemonade
-
Mules
fresh lime, ginger beer Texas: Tito’s vodka Smoked: siete misterios mezcal Seasonal: cinnamon-infused tequila, peach
-
Espresso Martini
tito's vodka, oro gold espresso, kahlua, lemon
-
The Fancy
vanilla vodka, cold brew coffee, chocolate, kahlua, cream agave
Wine
by the glass or perhaps, a bottle?-
Ca’del Doge Prosecco
Italy
-
Nicolas Idiart Rose
France
-
J.L Denois Sparkling Brut Rosé
Limoux, France
-
Picpoul de Pinet 2021
Jadix, France
-
La Vite Pinot Grigio
Sicily, Italy
-
Hei Matau Sauvignon Blanc NV
New Zealand
-
Raeburn Chardonnay
Russian River Valley, Sonoma County, California
-
Imagery Pinot Noir 2020
Glen Ellen, California
-
Castorani Montepulciano
Abruzzo, Italy
-
True Myth Cabernet Sauvignon
Paso Robles, California
Wine
buy the bottle-
Natures Revenge Pétillant Naturel 2021
Languedoc Roussillon, France
-
Sparkling Pointe Brut Seduction 2012
North Fork, New York
-
Morey Coffinet Chardonnay 2021
Côte-D'Or, Burgundy, France
-
Wolffer Estate Pinot Gris 2021
Sagaponack, New York
-
Domaine de la Charmoise Gamay 2018
Loire Valley, France
-
Morey Domaine Coffinet Pinot Noir 2021
Cote-D'OR Burgundy, France
-
Wolffer Estate Cabernet Franc 2019
Sagaponach, New York
-
McCall Vineyards Cabernet Franc Reserve 2014
Cutchogue, New York
-
Lamole di Lamole "Maggiolo" Chianti Classico 2021
Tuscany, Italy
-
Fattoria Montecchio "PRISCUS" Super Tuscan 2016
Tuscany, Italy
-
Domaine Santa Duc 'Les Quatre Terres' Cotes Du Rhone 2021
Rhone Valley, France
-
Paumanok Vineyards 'Assemblage' Bordeaux Blend 2015
Aquebogue, New York
-
Turnbull Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon 2020
Napa Valley, California
Beers
-
Rotating Draft Beer
three fresh kegs to choose from + Guinness Stout (m/p)
-
Fresh Cans
our favorite breweries on rotation
-
North Fork Brewing Run the Juice
-
Other Half Green City Dry-Hopped IPA
-
Talea Fruited Sour
-
Ghostfish Meteor Shower
-
Allagash White
-
Miller Lite
-
Peroni
-
Doc's Cider (GF)
Mocktails
-
Peach Punch
black cherry, peach nectar, lemon, club soda
-
Wicked Mint
grapefruit juice, mint, simple, lime, club soda
-
Ginger Dream
pineapple, ginger, lemon, club soda
Soft Drinks…
-
Mineral Water
-
Coca-Cola
-
Diet Coke
-
Sprite
-
Gingerale
-
Unsweetened Iced Tea
-
Lemonade
-
Root Beer
-
Gosling’s Ginger Beer
-
Apple Juice
-
Orange Juice
-
Pineapple Juice
-
Tomato Juice
-
Iced Coffee
-
Chocolate Milk
-
Milk
-
Hot Cocoa
All of our desserts are hand made & full of love.
Desserts
-
Oatmeal Pie
sweet custard & brown sugar pie, fresh whip
-
Chocolate Almond Tart (GF)
fresh whip, berries
-
Peanut Butter Cheesecake
Graham cracker crust, strawberry jam & peanut brittle
-
Brownie Sundae
tahini brownie bites (GF), toasted sesame, vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, fresh whip, amaro cherries
-
Gelato
choose from vanilla or chocolate
-
Sorbet
lemon or mango
-
The Fancy a/k/a liquid dessert
Tito's vodka, Griffo cold brew coffee liqueur, chocolate, Grady's cold brew, cream, agave
-
Chocolate Soufflé Cake
flourless chocolate cake, coffee toffee sauce, strawberries, fresh whip
For the kids...
Children 12 and under-
A Really Small Cheese Burger
4oz. Really Good Burger, cheddar, slider bun, first fries
-
Pasta
served plain or buttered
-
Chicken
grilled OR fried chicken breast, served with first fries
-
Fried Shrimp
first fries, lemon garlic aioli
-
Small Salad
seasonal lettuce & vegetables, honey & lemon vinaigrette
-
Grilled Cheese
first fries
For all groups from 8 - 16 we host with a set menu for ease of service, guaranteeing the best experience for all guests on property. Whether a special occasion or just a few families gathering for a meal we can provide custom options, accommodate all allergies and ages.
Our menu includes a cocktail, shared family style appetizers, and choice of entree.
Our kitchen can very easily accommodate guests with any allergies or dietary restrictions. We can tailor the menu to meet the needs of your party.
Price is typically $82 per person (plus 20% gratuity and taxes & fees) but fluctuates depending on menu, party size, date, etc.
This menu ensures everyone has an enjoyable experience.
Please email to reserve now! GM@FirstAndSouth.com
Options for your custom menu are detailed below.
Shared Appetizers
Multiple portions of some of our favorite starters, served family style.-
Kale Caesar Salad
curly kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, sliced apple, garlic croutons, caesar dressing
-
Mac & Cheese
four cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumb
-
First Fries
hand cut, triple blanched, made with love
-
Buffalo Wings
traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, carrot & celery
-
Crab Cakes
charred pineapple slaw, garlic wilted spinach, pickled red onion, piquillo pepper yogurt
-
Burrata
confit cherry tomatoes, garlic & shallots, basil pesto, radish sprouts, warm baguette
-
Roasted Beet Salad
whipped goat cheese, toasted pistachio, balsamic glaze, pickled red onion, arugula & fennel
Choice of Entree
Every selects their own entree from one of 4 choices. Typically our menus include one fish, steak, chicken, and vegetarian option. That way there is something for everyone!-
Angel Hair Pomodoro
blistered baby heirloom tomato, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nuts
-
Honey & Tangerine Salmon
sautéed rainbow chard, shiitake mushrooms, lemon butter, garlic, shallots, scallions, jasmine rice
-
Lemon Pepper Shrimp
white wine, garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, fusilli pasta, baguette
-
Really Good Burger
cheddar, steakhouse bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, served with first fries
-
Roast Chicken
wild mushroom bread pudding, wilted spinach, charred onion, almonds, marsala-caper sauce
-
Black Bean Burger
queso fresco, caramelized onion, guacamole, chipotle aioli, seasonal green salad
-
Steak Frites
plancha grilled hanger steak, green salad, first fries, black garlic-merlot demi
-
Saffron Mussels
lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette